I see from today's 'Herald' that Ronnie Smith, General Secretary of the teaching union EIS, is calling for the running of schools to be taken away from Scotland's 32 democratically elected local authorities and given over to quangos in the shape of 12 educational trusts.
Clearly what lies behind this proposal is the view that if schools were run by trusts they would in some way have greater protection from the cuts that local authorities are having to make in response to reduced funding from the Scottish Government. The experience of further and higher education institutions, which are directly funded by the Scottish Government, would suggest that this argument is somewhat naive.
The EIS General Secretary of course tries to advance a philosophical argument in favour of his Union's position.
He appears to be arguing that education is a national service and therefore all schools should operate on the basis of consistent national policies with no local flexibility. I totally reject this notion.
The delivery of education to our communities is fundamental to the role of local authorities and the purpose of local government. Indeed in the case of Inverclyde our whole social and economic strategy is underpinned by our commitment to giving our young people the best possible start in life to help lift many of them out of poverty. We should also not forget that most local councillors have a direct interest in ensuring that the education services we provide are of a high standard since our children and grandchildren are among the recipients of these services.
If you accept the logic of Mr Smith's argument then most, if not all, services would be removed from local authorities.
If education is a national service so by the same logic is social work. Why not therefore transfer social work to be run by appointed health boards?
If we are looking for consistent national standards why not transfer responsibility for local roads to Transport Scotland, which already manages the trunk roads network?
I could go on.
Mr Smith tells us that it would be important to ensure proper democratic accountability within the educational trusts so that local views and priorities are not overlooked, citing health boards as a possible blue print for how such trusts could operate.
Mr Smith would do well to ask the people of Inverclyde how accountable they feel that health boards are before before promoting such nonsense.
The fundamental point that Mr Smith is missing is that local authorities do not exist simply to deliver nationally agreed policies and priorities. We have a system of local government in Scotland not local administration.
Any political party that is considering removing education from local authority control would do well to think again. I am confident that this is something that would be opposed by the vast majority of councillors across the political spectrum.
Thursday 30 December 2010
Tuesday 28 December 2010
Strange bedfellows...
I see from the 'Scotsman' that former Tory Scottish Secretary Michael - now Lord - Forsyth is calling for a referendum before the tax powers for the Scottish Parliament proposed by the Calman Commission are introduced by the Westminster Parliament.
While I am not convinced of the need for a referendum - we had one in 1997 on the 3p tax power, which the Scottish Parliament has not used in 11 years - I do share Lord Forsyth's scepticism about these new powers (doesn't politics create some strange bedfellows?), although possibly for different reasons.
I just find it bizarre that Parliamentarians who have spent the last 11 years seeking to limit the ability of local government to use its tax raising powers, and not used the tax varying power given to them by the Scottish people, are so keen on additional tax varying powers. I have yet to hear a convincing case as to how these additional powers will be used to better the lives of the people of Scotland.
Can anyone help me in this regard?
While I am not convinced of the need for a referendum - we had one in 1997 on the 3p tax power, which the Scottish Parliament has not used in 11 years - I do share Lord Forsyth's scepticism about these new powers (doesn't politics create some strange bedfellows?), although possibly for different reasons.
I just find it bizarre that Parliamentarians who have spent the last 11 years seeking to limit the ability of local government to use its tax raising powers, and not used the tax varying power given to them by the Scottish people, are so keen on additional tax varying powers. I have yet to hear a convincing case as to how these additional powers will be used to better the lives of the people of Scotland.
Can anyone help me in this regard?
Wednesday 22 December 2010
Happy Christmas...
It hardly seems a year since my last Christmas message – it must be my age - and I think we can agree it has been an eventful and challenging 12 months for us all.
Despite the economic pressures, our prudence in setting a two year budget in 2008 enabled us to progress our programme of investment in Inverclyde, deliver on our political priorities and continue the modernisation of the Council.
2011 will bring further financial challenges as we face up to the difficult task of making budget savings due to funding cuts by the UK and Scottish Governments. There are no easy savings and there can be no escaping the fact that there will be reductions in the range of services we provide and the number of people we employ.
Despite this, 2011 should be another year of progress for Inverclyde.
In early 2011 we will celebrate the opening of Kilmacolm’s new community centre and public library.
In late spring we will see the completion of two fantastic new secondary schools in Greenock, Clydeview Academy and Notre Dame High School, as part of our £80m PPP project. In the autumn work will start on our exciting new shared campus in Port Glasgow and the new St Columba’s High School in Gourock.
2011 will see further significant progress with our Leisure Strategy. Work should start on the refurbishment of Ravenscraig Stadium; a new changing pavilion and community stadium at Parklea; and the upgrading of Gourock Pool.
Work will continue on our new £10m theatre at East India Harbour in Greenock and in July we will welcome back the Tall Ships Race: a major opportunity to showcase Inverclyde to the outside world.
2011 should see the completion of nearly 200 new homes by River Clyde Homes in Port Glasgow.
As you can see, there is much to look forward to.
Before closing, I would like to thank all Council staff for their efforts during the past year and in particular over the last few weeks dealing with the effects of an unprecedented cold snap. I would also like to offer my special thanks to those staff who will be keeping that effort going, working over the holiday period to maintain essential services.
I would like to wish you all a Happy Christmas and the very best for 2011.
Councillor Stephen McCabe
Leader of Inverclyde Council
Despite the economic pressures, our prudence in setting a two year budget in 2008 enabled us to progress our programme of investment in Inverclyde, deliver on our political priorities and continue the modernisation of the Council.
2011 will bring further financial challenges as we face up to the difficult task of making budget savings due to funding cuts by the UK and Scottish Governments. There are no easy savings and there can be no escaping the fact that there will be reductions in the range of services we provide and the number of people we employ.
Despite this, 2011 should be another year of progress for Inverclyde.
In early 2011 we will celebrate the opening of Kilmacolm’s new community centre and public library.
In late spring we will see the completion of two fantastic new secondary schools in Greenock, Clydeview Academy and Notre Dame High School, as part of our £80m PPP project. In the autumn work will start on our exciting new shared campus in Port Glasgow and the new St Columba’s High School in Gourock.
2011 will see further significant progress with our Leisure Strategy. Work should start on the refurbishment of Ravenscraig Stadium; a new changing pavilion and community stadium at Parklea; and the upgrading of Gourock Pool.
Work will continue on our new £10m theatre at East India Harbour in Greenock and in July we will welcome back the Tall Ships Race: a major opportunity to showcase Inverclyde to the outside world.
2011 should see the completion of nearly 200 new homes by River Clyde Homes in Port Glasgow.
As you can see, there is much to look forward to.
Before closing, I would like to thank all Council staff for their efforts during the past year and in particular over the last few weeks dealing with the effects of an unprecedented cold snap. I would also like to offer my special thanks to those staff who will be keeping that effort going, working over the holiday period to maintain essential services.
I would like to wish you all a Happy Christmas and the very best for 2011.
Councillor Stephen McCabe
Leader of Inverclyde Council
Tuesday 21 December 2010
Go ahead for MUGA...
Weather permitting, work should start on 10 January on the new £150,000 floodlit multi-use games area in Kilmacolm's Birkmyre Park.
At a special Council meeting last week permission was given to accept a tender from The Malcolm Group Ltd.
The MUGA - which will be available for a variety of sports, including football, tennis and netball - will be situated on the site of dilapidated tennis courts. This investment in Birkmyre Park adds to previous investments by the Council in the refurbishment of the pavilion and play area, and the re-opening of the putting green.
At a special Council meeting last week permission was given to accept a tender from The Malcolm Group Ltd.
The MUGA - which will be available for a variety of sports, including football, tennis and netball - will be situated on the site of dilapidated tennis courts. This investment in Birkmyre Park adds to previous investments by the Council in the refurbishment of the pavilion and play area, and the re-opening of the putting green.
I almost feel sorry for the Tories...
Following the latest difficulties with their Lib Dem Coalition partners - Vice Cable's unguarded comments to two Daily Telegraph journalists - I almost feel sorry for the Tories.
I suspect many of them are now thinking that they should have tried to run a minority government rather than enter into a coalition with the most unprincipled party in British politics.
It looks increasingly unlikely to me that the coalition will last the full five years of this Parliament.
I only hope that if Labour is the biggest party after next year's Scottish Parliament election we are very wary of entering into another coalition with the Lib Dems.
I suspect many of them are now thinking that they should have tried to run a minority government rather than enter into a coalition with the most unprincipled party in British politics.
It looks increasingly unlikely to me that the coalition will last the full five years of this Parliament.
I only hope that if Labour is the biggest party after next year's Scottish Parliament election we are very wary of entering into another coalition with the Lib Dems.
Sunday 19 December 2010
The week ahead...
The final working week before Christmas.
Monday
7.30 Start work in Glasgow
1.00 Leave work to travel to Port Glasgow
1.30 Attending Joint Carol Service for St Michael's and Newark Primary Schools
3.30 Chairing a Meeting of the Inverclyde Alliance Board
6.30 Chairing a meeting of the Shared Campus Working Group
Tuesday
At work all day. In the evening I have a surgery at Woodhall Tenants' Hall
Wednesday
7.30 Start work in Glasgow
1.00 Leave work to travel to Greenock
2.00 Inaugural meeting of Inverclyde Community Health and Care Partnership Committee
3.00 Weekly meeting with the Chief Executive
Thursday and Friday
At work all day with no Council commitments
Monday
7.30 Start work in Glasgow
1.00 Leave work to travel to Port Glasgow
1.30 Attending Joint Carol Service for St Michael's and Newark Primary Schools
3.30 Chairing a Meeting of the Inverclyde Alliance Board
6.30 Chairing a meeting of the Shared Campus Working Group
Tuesday
At work all day. In the evening I have a surgery at Woodhall Tenants' Hall
Wednesday
7.30 Start work in Glasgow
1.00 Leave work to travel to Greenock
2.00 Inaugural meeting of Inverclyde Community Health and Care Partnership Committee
3.00 Weekly meeting with the Chief Executive
Thursday and Friday
At work all day with no Council commitments
Saturday 18 December 2010
Lib Dem MSP slams Coastguard plans...
I see that Lib Dem West of Scotland Regional MSP Ross Finnie has slammed the decision of the Con Dem Coalition Government to close Greenock's Coastguard Centre.
At least Ross is being consistent, since he attacked the previous Labour Government when the MOD decided to close the Navy Buildings in Eldon Street, leading to concern that the Coastguard could relocate out of Inverclyde.
Now his own party have gone a step further.
Hopefully Ross will be able to use his influence with Nick Clegg to have this decision reversed?
At least Ross is being consistent, since he attacked the previous Labour Government when the MOD decided to close the Navy Buildings in Eldon Street, leading to concern that the Coastguard could relocate out of Inverclyde.
Now his own party have gone a step further.
Hopefully Ross will be able to use his influence with Nick Clegg to have this decision reversed?
Sunday 12 December 2010
The week ahead...
Monday
At work all day. In the evening I am due to attend a meeting of Kilmacolm Primary School Parent Partnership.
Tuesday
7.30 Start work in Glasgow
2.00 Leave work to travel to Greenock
4.00 Special Meetings of Inverclyde Council
7.00 Meeting of St Columba's High School Working Group
Wednesday
7.30 Start work in Glasgow
11.00 Leave work to travel to Paisley
11.30 Meeting at Renfrewshire Council regarding Clyde Muirshiel Regional Park
1.00 Meeting with Council Officers in Greenock
2.30 Event to mark the completion of work at the West Stewart Street Underpass in Greenock
3.30 Meeting of Central Gourock Working Group
4.30 Weekly meeting of the Administration Group
5.30 Weekly meeting of the Labour Group
Thursday
At work all day and into the evening
Friday
At work in the morning with the afternoon off for our Christmas Lunch
At work all day. In the evening I am due to attend a meeting of Kilmacolm Primary School Parent Partnership.
Tuesday
7.30 Start work in Glasgow
2.00 Leave work to travel to Greenock
4.00 Special Meetings of Inverclyde Council
7.00 Meeting of St Columba's High School Working Group
Wednesday
7.30 Start work in Glasgow
11.00 Leave work to travel to Paisley
11.30 Meeting at Renfrewshire Council regarding Clyde Muirshiel Regional Park
1.00 Meeting with Council Officers in Greenock
2.30 Event to mark the completion of work at the West Stewart Street Underpass in Greenock
3.30 Meeting of Central Gourock Working Group
4.30 Weekly meeting of the Administration Group
5.30 Weekly meeting of the Labour Group
Thursday
At work all day and into the evening
Friday
At work in the morning with the afternoon off for our Christmas Lunch
Friday 10 December 2010
Not as good as it was made out...
I attended a meeting of the COSLA Convention in Edinburgh today, where there was a growing recognition on the part of Councils - including some of those who enthusiastically endorsed the package only a few weeks ago - that the financial deal on the table from the Scottish Government is not as good as it was made out to be.
Officers of our Council are still working on the figures supplied by the Scottish Government and seeking further information, so it is too early to say if Inverclyde's cut is higher or lower than the 2.6% average.
The full Council will consider a report on the two-year budget position for 2011-13 on Tuesday and will decide whether or not we are prepared to sign up to the Government's offer. If we do agree to sign up there will be a number of conditions attached, outlining what we would require of the Scottish Government before we finalise our budget.
One thing that has angered many Council Leaders however is the severity of the sanction that would be imposed by the Government on those Councils that do not sign up, which in Inverclyde's case would amount to an additional cut of over £7.5m. We believe that what they are proposing is an affront to democracy and that the Cabinet should hang their heads in shame.
Officers of our Council are still working on the figures supplied by the Scottish Government and seeking further information, so it is too early to say if Inverclyde's cut is higher or lower than the 2.6% average.
The full Council will consider a report on the two-year budget position for 2011-13 on Tuesday and will decide whether or not we are prepared to sign up to the Government's offer. If we do agree to sign up there will be a number of conditions attached, outlining what we would require of the Scottish Government before we finalise our budget.
One thing that has angered many Council Leaders however is the severity of the sanction that would be imposed by the Government on those Councils that do not sign up, which in Inverclyde's case would amount to an additional cut of over £7.5m. We believe that what they are proposing is an affront to democracy and that the Cabinet should hang their heads in shame.
Tuesday 7 December 2010
The only topic of coversation...
Often in our daily lives we pass pleasantries with other people about the weather.
At present it seems to be the only topic of conversation.
Leaving home just after 6.30 this morning I somehow managed to get to work in Govan for 7.25, crawling along at an average of 20 miles per hour. Many of my work colleagues were unable to make it in for a variety of reasons.
With my children off school again tomorrow it looks like it will be my turn to take the day off to watch them.
I had a surgery in Park Farm Community Hall tonight. On the way there my car got stuck in Mull Avenue, so I had to walk the rest of the way on foot. On reaching the Hall I quickly agreed with the hall keeper that no one in their right mind would be coming out tonight, so the surgery was cancelled. Fortunately I was able to get my car unstuck and travel back safely to Kilmacolm.
Who knows what tomorrow will bring!
At present it seems to be the only topic of conversation.
Leaving home just after 6.30 this morning I somehow managed to get to work in Govan for 7.25, crawling along at an average of 20 miles per hour. Many of my work colleagues were unable to make it in for a variety of reasons.
With my children off school again tomorrow it looks like it will be my turn to take the day off to watch them.
I had a surgery in Park Farm Community Hall tonight. On the way there my car got stuck in Mull Avenue, so I had to walk the rest of the way on foot. On reaching the Hall I quickly agreed with the hall keeper that no one in their right mind would be coming out tonight, so the surgery was cancelled. Fortunately I was able to get my car unstuck and travel back safely to Kilmacolm.
Who knows what tomorrow will bring!
Monday 6 December 2010
The novelty is wearing off...fast!
What weather we are having!
When I left Kilmacolm just before 7.00 this morning there was no snow, just some light rain.
At about 8.30 I looked out of my office window in Govan to see that it was snowing heavily. Just before 12.00 I set off from work to return home after the decision was taken to close the office. Over two hours later I finally got out of Glasgow and onto the M8!
The novelty of this weather is certainly wearing off fast.
When I left Kilmacolm just before 7.00 this morning there was no snow, just some light rain.
At about 8.30 I looked out of my office window in Govan to see that it was snowing heavily. Just before 12.00 I set off from work to return home after the decision was taken to close the office. Over two hours later I finally got out of Glasgow and onto the M8!
The novelty of this weather is certainly wearing off fast.
Sunday 5 December 2010
The week ahead...
Monday
7.30 Start work in Glasgow
2.00 Leave work to travel to Greenock
3.00 Meeting with the trade unions regarding the Council's Budget
4.30 Weekly meeting of the Labour Group
6.30 Meeting of the Council's Shared Campus Working Group
Tuesday
At work all day. In the evening I have a surgery at Boglestone Community Centre.
Wednesday
7.30 Start work in Glasgow
1.00 Leave work to travel to Kilmacolm
1.30 Kilmacolm Primary School Nativity Show
3.30 Weekly meeting with the Chief Executive
4.30 Weekly meeting of the Administration Group
Thursday
9.30 Start work in Glasgow
3.00 Leave work to travel to Greenock
4.00 Meeting with Strathclyde Partnership for Transport (SPT)
Friday
At the COSLA Convention in Edinburgh most of the day,then going to work in Glasgow for a few hours in the afternoon.
7.30 Start work in Glasgow
2.00 Leave work to travel to Greenock
3.00 Meeting with the trade unions regarding the Council's Budget
4.30 Weekly meeting of the Labour Group
6.30 Meeting of the Council's Shared Campus Working Group
Tuesday
At work all day. In the evening I have a surgery at Boglestone Community Centre.
Wednesday
7.30 Start work in Glasgow
1.00 Leave work to travel to Kilmacolm
1.30 Kilmacolm Primary School Nativity Show
3.30 Weekly meeting with the Chief Executive
4.30 Weekly meeting of the Administration Group
Thursday
9.30 Start work in Glasgow
3.00 Leave work to travel to Greenock
4.00 Meeting with Strathclyde Partnership for Transport (SPT)
Friday
At the COSLA Convention in Edinburgh most of the day,then going to work in Glasgow for a few hours in the afternoon.
Saturday 4 December 2010
Christmas Fun...
Following the disappointment of the cancellation of last night's Christmas Lights Switch-Ons it was back to Christmas duty this morning when I opened the St Michael's Primary School Christmas Fete.
Despite the weather, there was a very good turnout of parents and family members to support the school and I am sure that a significant sum was raised for school funds.
Well done to everyone who put in a great effort to make this event such a success.
Despite the weather, there was a very good turnout of parents and family members to support the school and I am sure that a significant sum was raised for school funds.
Well done to everyone who put in a great effort to make this event such a success.
Thursday 2 December 2010
World Cup Disappointment...
I was deeply disappointed to hear that England had missed out on hosting the 2018 World Cup. I suppose that's what happens when you elect a Tory government.
As a football fan I was looking forward to the World Cup coming to the UK in 8 years time. It looks as if it could be a long time yet before football comes home again.
As a football fan I was looking forward to the World Cup coming to the UK in 8 years time. It looks as if it could be a long time yet before football comes home again.
More Christmas Spirit...
It might just have been the time of the year - everyone getting in the Christmas spirit - but we had a relatively quiet full Council today. The local press must have anticipated this as they did not bother to turn up.
Members heard that by virtue of a 25 minute appearance at a recent General Purposes Board SNP Councillor Jim Grieve is permitted a further 6 months of absence from Council meetings before he would automatically be removed from office. Hopefully Jim will be fit to return to his duties in the near future.
There were a number of appointments made.
My Labour colleague Jim Clocherty was appointed unopposed to replace my former Labour colleague Charlie McCallum, who recently resigned from the Human Resources Board, for reasons that I am not quite clear about.
Charlie in turn was appointed to the Prison Visiting Committee of the new HMP Low Moss. Some wag - who shall remain nameless - was overheard saying that he would be more than happy to send Charlie to Low Moss!
More contentious were the appointments to the Board of Greenock Arts Guild and Discover Inverclyde.
Jim Clocherty was appointed unopposed to the Arts Guild, by vitue of the fact that he is Convener of the Regeneration Committee, while SNP Councillor Chris Osborne - yes he of the other less interesting blog - narrowly beat Lib Dem Leader Alan Blair, and apparent culture vulture, in a vote for the second position.
Independent Councillor Ronnie Ahlfeld beat off competition from former Lib Dem Provost Ciano Rebecchi and SNP Group Leader, and renowned world traveller, Jim MacLeod, for the Discover Inverclyde position.
Democracy in action!
Members heard that by virtue of a 25 minute appearance at a recent General Purposes Board SNP Councillor Jim Grieve is permitted a further 6 months of absence from Council meetings before he would automatically be removed from office. Hopefully Jim will be fit to return to his duties in the near future.
There were a number of appointments made.
My Labour colleague Jim Clocherty was appointed unopposed to replace my former Labour colleague Charlie McCallum, who recently resigned from the Human Resources Board, for reasons that I am not quite clear about.
Charlie in turn was appointed to the Prison Visiting Committee of the new HMP Low Moss. Some wag - who shall remain nameless - was overheard saying that he would be more than happy to send Charlie to Low Moss!
More contentious were the appointments to the Board of Greenock Arts Guild and Discover Inverclyde.
Jim Clocherty was appointed unopposed to the Arts Guild, by vitue of the fact that he is Convener of the Regeneration Committee, while SNP Councillor Chris Osborne - yes he of the other less interesting blog - narrowly beat Lib Dem Leader Alan Blair, and apparent culture vulture, in a vote for the second position.
Independent Councillor Ronnie Ahlfeld beat off competition from former Lib Dem Provost Ciano Rebecchi and SNP Group Leader, and renowned world traveller, Jim MacLeod, for the Discover Inverclyde position.
Democracy in action!
Wednesday 1 December 2010
Getting in the Christmas Spirit...
I attended the switch-on of the Christmas Lights in Port Glasgow this evening.
Children from the local primaries were in great voice, signing carols as we awaited the arrival of Santa. As usual, the Salvation Army Band provided the musical accompaniment.
Despite the weather, there was a good turnout at the event and my colleague Robert Moran was in fine form as master of ceremonies.
At least for half an hour we were able to get into the Christmas Spirit and forget about these troubled times.
Children from the local primaries were in great voice, signing carols as we awaited the arrival of Santa. As usual, the Salvation Army Band provided the musical accompaniment.
Despite the weather, there was a good turnout at the event and my colleague Robert Moran was in fine form as master of ceremonies.
At least for half an hour we were able to get into the Christmas Spirit and forget about these troubled times.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
